Re: Kavod Hatzibbur (Women and Kriat Megilla)
Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

Re: Kavod Hatzibbur (Women and Kriat Megilla)

February 08, 1999 05:00AM
<HTML>R. Yehudah Herzl Henkin, Sh'elot U'teshuvot Bnei Banim I, 4 (P. 17)
suggests that k'vod hatzibbur, in connection with women reading the
Torah (and presumably, by extension, regarding megillah reading, for
those rishonim who apply k'vod hatzibbur to it) means that having a
woman read the Torah would seem to imply that the men are unable to do
so for themselves. Presumably this implication is based on the fact
that the core minyan is composed of men (although women also belong to
the broader tzibbur participating in the Torah reading - and certainly
in megillah reading - as evidenced by the halakhah in Shulhan Arukh,
Orah Haim 134:2), and so having a woman read would be similar to Mishnah
Sukkah 3:10 and Bavli Berakhot 20b.

There are aharonim who have noted that k'vod hatzibbur - in some
contexts - is really k'vod shamayim, see for example Taz Orah Haim 53:2
and R. Akiva Eiger to Orah Haim 143:2.</HTML>
Subject Author Posted

Kavod Hatzibbur (Women and Kriat Megilla)

Tzvi Pittinsky February 05, 1999 05:00AM

Re: Kavod Hatzibbur (Women and Kriat Megilla)

Shalom Berger February 05, 1999 05:00AM

Re: Kavod Hatzibbur (Women and Kriat Megilla)

Avie Walfish February 08, 1999 05:00AM

Re: Kavod Hatzibbur (Women and Kriat Megilla)

Rabbi Howard Jachter February 08, 1999 05:00AM

Re: Kavod Hatzibbur (Women and Kriat Megilla)

Barbara Freedman February 22, 1999 05:00AM



Author:

Your Email:


Subject:


banner class does not have character X defined in its font.