Re: Difficult topics to teach: Sotah
Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

Re: Difficult topics to teach: Sotah

March 11, 1999 05:00AM
<HTML>I recently taught sotah to eighth grade girls, all of whom were orthodox.
The embarrassment of the sotah was an issue for them. There is a constant
theme of midah kneged midah, especially in Rashi. One could take this
approach a bit further: she sinned in private by uncovering her body, so
she is shamed in public in a similar manner.

Generally, I emphasized all of the improper conduct that had to take place
before she could ever get to Yerushalaim: warnings private and public, her
willful yichud despite warnings, bet din, etc. And of course, she can
"opt out" and almost any stage in the process (how many guilty sotahs were
there in history?). The four perakim of sotah in the Rambam lay out
everything quite nicely.

I hope this is of some help despite the age difference. (Perhaps sotah
isn't the best topic for 7-year-old girls).

Jonathan Marvin</HTML>
Subject Author Posted

Difficult topics to teach: Sotah

Elliott Kohn March 09, 1999 05:00AM

Re: Difficult topics to teach: Sotah

Jonathan Marvin March 11, 1999 05:00AM

Re: Difficult topics to teach: Sotah

Warren Braham March 15, 1999 05:00AM

Re: Difficult topics to teach: Sotah

Barbara Freedman March 14, 1999 05:00AM

Re: Difficult topics to teach: Sotah

Rabbi Chaim Kosofsky March 15, 1999 05:00AM

Re: Difficult topics to teach: Sotah

Mindy S. Kornberg March 16, 1999 05:00AM

Re: Difficult topics to teach: Sotah

Jeremiah Unterman March 15, 1999 05:00AM

Re: Difficult topics to teach: Sotah

Esther Kosofsky March 15, 1999 05:00AM

A Modest Pedagogical Proposal

M. Sokolw March 17, 1999 05:00AM

Re: Difficult topics to teach: Sotah

Jeffery Spitzer March 18, 1999 05:00AM

Re: Difficult topics to teach: Sotah

Shmuel Afek March 18, 1999 05:00AM

Re: Difficult topics to teach: Sotah

Avner Taler March 22, 1999 05:00AM

Re: Difficult topics to teach: Sotah

Shalom Carmy March 22, 1999 05:00AM

Re: Difficult topics to teach: Sotah

Steve Bailey October 29, 2007 12:15PM

Re: Difficult topics to teach: Sotah

Moshe Shoshan October 29, 2007 12:41PM

Re: Difficult topics to teach: Sotah

David Resnick October 29, 2007 12:42PM

Re: Difficult topics to teach: Sotah

Michael Berkowitz October 29, 2007 12:43PM

Re: Difficult topics to teach: Sotah

Jeremiah Unterman October 30, 2007 09:01AM

Re: Difficult topics to teach: Sotah

Zvi Leshem November 15, 2007 10:10AM

Re: Difficult topics to teach

Moshe Abelesz November 15, 2007 10:11AM



Author:

Your Email:


Subject:


banner class does not have character Y defined in its font.