Category: Search for Spirituality (Winter 2007)
Steven Bailey is Associate Professor in the Faculty of Education at York University, Toronto, Canada, specializing in Jewish Teacher Education.
I believe that the answer to the question in the title is: No. I don’t believe we can teach spirituality – at least, not directly. But the good news is: While spirituality cannot be taught directly, I think students can be taught to experience meaning and positive affect within religious ideas and practices, which will facilitate their personal spiritual quest within Judaism.
Before elaborating, I need to define the abstract term, "spiritual experience," to move it from an “airy-fairy” notion of communing with the universe to a more definable concept that we can work with as teachers, in the context of Jewish education.
Foremost, spirituality is a personal experience. I propose that when “spiritual” refers to a Jewish religious experience in an educational context, it connotes a student’s experience of a personal connection with God through ideas, prayer or practice. This connection is personal and in contrast to the general religious relationship with God shared by all identified Jews. As such, although a teacher can directly address students’ Jewish identity (the Jewish people’s shared relationship with God) through teaching and activities (for example, Israel, community service and general social mitzvot), a teacher cannot legislate or impose on his or her students, a personal connection with God.
To further refine the concept of spirituality, before we address facilitating its development in our students, we turn to a study by Martsolf and Mickley (1998), which addressed the issue of nurses’ attempts to assess the spiritual needs of patients as part of a holistic approach to treatment. Noting that the concept of spirituality means different things to different people, the researchers listed five key concepts that arose when people were asked to describe what spirituality means to them:
- Making sense of situations; deriving meaning and purpose
- Cherishing values, beliefs, standards and ethics
- Awareness, and appreciation of a "transcendent dimension" to life beyond self
- Connecting with self, others, God, and nature
- Awareness of a sense of who one is, through reflection and experience
Although these reflect nurses’ belief’s about spirituality, all of their characteristics relate to spirituality as I am defining it for education. Our question, therefore, focuses on how teachers can facilitate a personal connection with God through learning, prayer and mitzvot, which incorporates the diverse definitions of spirituality as described above. In other words, how can we facilitate that which conveys meaning and cherished values, an increase in awareness of going beyond the self and a connection with God through self-reflection and personal experience?
David Krathwohl’s Affective Taxonomy
A useful model for educators wanting to facilitate spirituality (as we’ve defined it), comes from the educational field of “affective learning” – specifically, from the affective domain taxonomy of David Krathwohl (1964). Krathwohl developed an affective taxonomy similar to Bloom’s cognitive taxonomy, where a sequential structure of activities reflects the developing personal relationship and value systems of the student. The focus and purpose of the model, as he has developed it, is to move the student towards a meaningful and purposeful internalization of values and beliefs through sequential levels of activities. Both values and beliefs have an affective component to them – they are personally satisfying and valued as “good” or “right” – and thus, adopted into the developing personality of the student.
I believe Krathwohl’s affective learning goal – the internalization of values and beliefs – is the means by which Jewish educators can facilitate the experience of personal “Jewish spirituality” in their students. In effect, I wish to blend Krathwohl’s taxonomy with our goal of inspiring our students – that is say that since we cannot directly teach spirituality, we can use the model to build up a positive, learned affective association with the ideas, experiences or practices, which then may be internalized and transform into the characteristics of a spiritual experience in those students who are receptive.
Krathwohl’s taxonomy has five levels, which I’ll briefly describe and then use illustratively. The first level requires the teacher to get her students to willingly attend to the particular value or practice being taught. In other words, it needs to be personally relevant to the student. The second level focuses on a positive, proactive response from the student, associating the value or practice with positive affect. Then, moving towards internalization of the value, the student begins to accept, commit to and prefer the value as personally meaningful. Next, in level four, comes the conceptualization of the value in terms of ordering it and integrating it as a meaningful component of a personal “philosophy of life.” Finally, at the last level, the value is internalized and integrated into the complex of the student’s character and personal motivation. It is at these last two stages that students experience a sense of personal meaning and positive value and make the belief or practice their own. In my view, if the value being taught reflects personal relationship with God, such as prayer, Torah-learning or meaningful mitzvot – internalization of that value is likely to inspire personal spiritual experience, as we’ve defined it.
An Illustrative Example: Tefillah
I’ve presented abstract theoretical constructs, so let’s take a look at a concrete illustration. How might this model be applied as a strategy to address the ubiquitous Jewish educational problem of facilitating the spiritual experience of tefillah in Jewish schools? The problem, to which most educators can attest, is a sense of meaninglessness, rote-behavior, boredom or indifference to the school (and synagogue?) group prayer experience, as reported by most students. Educators want prayer to be personally meaningful, a source of inspiration – a sense of communication with God. How do we facilitate these goals?
I am going to use a middle-school class (say, grade 7) of a community day school for my illustration. My assumption is that the community day school population is generally pluralistic and represents a wide range of “spiritual-connectivity” among the student body. I am also going to take some liberties with explicating and applying Krathwohl’s model, describing it as developed in my practicum course for my teacher candidates –often using extant creative methodology – so that the illustration is more "user-friendly" for Jewish education.
Before reading the illustration, please note four points.
- The focus of the model in the initial stages is on the experiential-affective, rather than on the cognitive, and I use the method of teacher’s self-disclosure to focus the student on the affective experience. The cognitive component is added later.
- Most activity involves each student participating by writing down reflections or journal entries, so that every student is involved personally rather than vicariously.
- Although I give illustrative statements by the teacher, this is a guided model to be integrated into a particular educator’s teaching style and classroom methodology, not a script.
- Finally, as you think about Krathwohl’s levels, bear in mind that his is a stage theory that requires each level to be achieved before going on to the next – and that one cannot skip levels. According to Krathwohl’s model, we often make the mistake of focusing on the cognitive before the affective, which violates the order of the levels. Remember that each level may take several classes and various activities; it is not meant as a simple, one-shot approach.
Level 1. Getting their attention
The goal of the initial level is to encourage the student to attend to the specific value or practice, making it personally relevant. A teacher might focus attention by personal disclosure and by asking for personal responses from students. Given that teachers are models (like it or not), a teacher may say:
When I go to synagogue, it’s important for me that it is a meaningful, personal experience between me and God. I see it as an opportunity to communicate with God – what is the experience like for you?
From this self-disclosing and student-focused statement, students hear that the prayer experience is an important value/practice for you, their teacher (whom they respect) and that encourages a few students to share their personal experiences. Such initial discussion captures the attention of the class on the subject and focuses them on the positive affect, not the behavior or cognitive components.
Level 2. Encouraging a positive response
Level Two focuses on the students’ responding to the value or practice in some positive way. At this level students seek activities through which they can discover satisfaction. This directs us to not dwell on the negativity and complaints which are sure to dominate students’ current reactions to their school prayer experience, but rather to intentionally move the responses in a positive direction. The teacher might say:
I know we often find prayers boring and rote, like you’ve said, but I want to hear some positive experiences. I know that every once in a while, when I concentrate on my chance to ‘talk with God’, I think about things I want for my family and for myself and find myself asking God for help. I am sure that many of you have had that experience. Who has?
The teacher intentionally moves away from the negative and directs the students to think positively. Rather than class discussion, often dominated by a few articulate students, this stage (and subsequent levels) requires personal involvement of all students. Thus, the teacher may present a brief assignment to personalize a response from each student. For example, she may ask all students to record one or two positive moments during the next prayer session and share what they were thinking with the class. Note that the explicit goal is to associate positive affect with the experience.
Level 3. Developing Commitment to the value/practice
At the next Krathwohl level, students begin the internalization process. This requires a developing commitment to the value as demonstrated by both an acceptance of it as worthy and preference for it in relation to other behaviors. To be of worth to the student, the experience needs to be personally relevant and valued. A teacher might discuss the following:
Although we’ve learned that some of prayer is praise of God, we also learned that most of prayer is about us asking for important things that we cannot get for ourselves as well as expressing gratitude to God for what we have. Over the next week, I’d like you to keep a little journal of things you ask for during prayer and also the things that you, personally, are grateful for – I’ll do the same and then we’ll discuss some of these in class.
This assignment focuses on making the experience personally relevant and worthy in the student’s life. The idea of journal-writing encourages the active reflection on the practice of “asking-thanking” during prayer, which helps to develop each student’s commitment to the personal experience of communicating with God during the regular tefillah time. At this stage, students get committed to the task and often encourage others to take it seriously.
To address the issue of preference, the teacher might discuss the following:
When I pray, I often find my mind wandering. I think about my lesson plan, the papers I have to grade, the reports I have to write – and not about talking with God. But then I think: I’ll have time to deal with those things in half an hour, now it’s more important for me to relax, concentrate and think about me and God. How do you get back to focusing on tefillah when you get distracted by other things you have to do?
Once again, the focus is on the positive and the teacher uses self-disclosure to direct the student’s attention to preferring – or valuing – the tefillah experience over inevitable distractions. Both these techniques encourage the beginnings of internalization of the acceptance of and preference for the tefillah experience as a positive value.
Level 4. Integrating tefilah experience into one’s “philosophy of life”
This penultimate stage represents the actual integration of the value into one’s ‘self ’ – specifically into one’s Jewish identity. Having experienced the positive values associated with prayer in the affective domain, the time is ripe for enhancing the meaningfulness of the experience through cognitive means. Specifically, through more philosophical discussion (obviously at an age-appropriate level) of how tefillah integrates with one’s Jewish life. Here the teacher can do some text-based learning from the siddur and connect it to the affective experience already developed. It might sound something like this:
We’ve been talking about our experiences of asking and thanking God, so as to not take our everyday life for granted. Let’s take a look at the list of brakhot we say as we begin tefillah each day. These were designed by our Rabbis to express our thanks to God each morning, especially for things we may take for granted. Look for the brakhot that you see as personal and re-write them in language that is personally meaningful for you. For example, thanking God for ‘clothing the naked’ could be re-written: "Thank you, God, for providing my family with the income to buy me the clothes I need for school each day, for sports, for dressing up for parties and for just hanging out with my friends. I know many kids my age don’t have these things; I feel grateful for everything in my closet!"
The teacher is connecting tefillah with text in a personally meaningful way that can be incorporated into the positive experience of “talking with God” already developed. The items discussed are relevant to the student’s everyday life and encourages a “philosophy of life” that incorporates the ongoing Jewish value of gratitude.
The teacher may also discuss the experience of tefillah at unstructured times (not during communal prayers) so as to further imbed the experience into the individual’s personal life. Depending on the age of students, the teacher may address more philosophical beliefs, including the personal responsibilities of a Jew reflected in structured prayer, as well as the ideas behind the concept of praising God. Whatever your specific curricular goals, the point at this level, is to build on the affective domain, through enhancing the cognitive aspects of the prayer experience, while encouraging the experience of tefillah (formal/informal) as part of one’s everyday life.
Level 5. Prayer as a character trait
This is the final level of Krathwohl’s model to which the educator has been aspiring. It describes the incorporation or internalization (in Krathwohl’s language) of the value being taught into one’s character, so that the valued practice becomes a trait of the student. In our case, achieving this final level would mean the internalization of, and a commitment to, the prayer experience of communicating with God in a positive, personally meaningful way, reflecting what we’ve called a “spiritual” experience. This means that the student is more likely to willingly participate in prayer (become a leader or reader/singer), encourage others to participate and even seek out prayer experiences outside of the school (like increased frequency of voluntary synagogue attendance).
The model as a guide
I have presented this model as a guide to facilitating the potential for spiritual experience in our students, using prayer in middle school as an illustrative example. Krathwohl’s model (at least my interpretation) can be used for other potentially spiritual experiences and with older students. As I mentioned above, one has to be aware of the developmental-stage aspect of the model. Although the model can be used for all ages – with age-appropriate modifications – the cognitive element necessarily requires appropriate cognitive-stage readiness. My example of tefillah, for instance, can be used for second grade as well as high school, since it involves issues of gratitude and personal needs, but the actual methodology would need to be adjusted for age related cognitive skills, as reflected in a spiral curriculum.
Let me briefly comment on another ubiquitous “spiritual” problem-area that has potential application for Krathwohl’s model as a gateway to spiritual experience. We are often frustrated by adolescents who show a sense of indifference or low-value to the serious study and analyses of Jewish texts, whether biblical or Talmudic. Students are often bored, fail to see the connection of the traditional texts to their life and remain unmotivated to expend the necessary energy for thoughtful class discussions. A class in Tanakh often becomes a matter of taking teacher-dictated notes or studying translations and memorizing commentaries. An excerpt of Mishnah or Talmud is often experienced as irrelevant to a student’s real life and no different from having to study calculus, simply as a cognitive challenge. In contrast, many of us, as teachers, experience the deep study of texts as a spiritual experience, connecting us to God’s “thoughts” (biblical) or to profound Rabbinic wisdom, and we wish our students could share the enjoyment and intense satisfaction. Can Torah learning become a spiritual experience for students?
According to this model – yes. But a curricular plan would have to go through the affective-learning model’s five levels, step-by-step, in order to develop the personally meaningful connection with the text as a positively valued “beyond-the-self” spiritual experience. Remember, also, that genuine appreciation of the spiritual dimension of text learning (or the spiritual dimension of Shabbat) would likely have to wait until high school or adult education, since students' life experiences play an important factor in their sense of personal meaningfulness and relevance. I’d encourage some of my creative colleagues to attack this challenge – with developmental sensitivity – guided by Krathwohl’s five levels, and share their results.
To sum up: Since we can’t impose spirituality, the best we can do is encourage our students’ quest for positive, deeply meaningful experiences, which transcend the self and provide purpose to their Jewish lives. Doing that provides us educators with a spiritual experience of our own! I believe that Krathwohl’s method of internalizing values on the affective domain is as close to this goal as we can get.
References
Krathwohl, David R., Bloom, Benjamin S., and Masia, Bertram B. (1964). Taxonomy of educational objectives: The classification of educational goals. Handbook II: Affective domain. New York: David McKay Co., Inc.
Martsolf, D.S and Mickley, J.R. (1998). The concept of spirituality in nursing theories: Differing world-views and extent of focus. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 27, 294-303.

