Teaching Tanakh

Jewish Education Amidst Rising Antisemitism  volume 22:2 Winter 2024

Teaching Tanakh: A New Perspective on Pedagogy

It is one of the oldest literary collections ever written and still very much in circulation. Public readings (and celebrations) of its text are practiced in nearly every synagogue in the world in a regular, fixed cycle. It has been analyzed and studied by religious luminaries, academic scholars, and lay people, and has been studied and taught more times than we can count, with hundreds if not thousands of published commentaries. It plays a central role in all of our lives.

One would think that by now we would have a pretty clear idea of what content from Tanakh should be taught and how it should be approached pedagogically at various age levels. And yet, a mountain of anecdotal evidence reveals that there is a huge range in what is taught, why it is taught, and how it is taught. Over the last three decades I have run countless Tanakh trainings and bootcamps and coached Tanakh teachers across grade levels and in Jewish schools around the world. While the focus is always a bit different, the goal is always to help each of these teachers develop a curriculum, or lesson, or approach appropriate for their respective schools. While there is some overlap, the materials produced with each teacher we work with are so dramatically different from each other, so uniquely targeted to that group of students in that particular community. Scholars have demonstrated that every era has produced its own commentary. It is likely that every generation has produced its own pedagogy and goals as well.

And so, the core questions about Tanakh education still confront us. How do we engage our students so that they will want to continue to study Tanakh? How do we equip our students with the tools for becoming independent Tanakh learners? How do we foster an identification with the messages of Tanakh so that our students will turn to it as a source of wisdom, insight, and inspiration? It is these questions which sit at the core of this issue of the journal.

 

BIVRAKHA,

RABBI ZVI GRUMET, ED.D.

Gratz College Master's Degree in Antisemitism Studies
Gratz College Master's Degree in Antisemitism Studies
The Barkai Method for Teaching Humash

The Barkai Method for Teaching Humash

In the introduction to his book Who Knows Twelve, Rabbi Berel Wein explores a troubling phenomenon: the growing disconnect between the Jewish people and their sacred texts. Whatever the causes for its decline may have been, many Jewish day schools today are attempting to reinvigorate the study of Tanakh, recognizing its fundamental role in Jewish identity and education. Maimonides codified the necessity of studying Tanakh in Hilkhot Talmud Torah (1:7), asserting that it is a crucial component of Jewish life. Today, there is a growing recognition of the need to revive these ancient texts, which hold profound significance for Zionism, community, ethics, spirituality, identity, and much more. One noteworthy example of this revival is the Barkai educational system, developed in Israel by Rav Dan Be’eri more than 40 years ago.

Introducing Sod Into the Tanakh Classroom

Introducing Sod Into the Tanakh Classroom

In my years of teaching Neviim and Ketuvim, one of my overarching goals was for students to gain an appreciation of why specific commentaries approached the same text differently. I spent significant time on both peshat and derash approaches, highlighting the strengths and weaknesses of each interpretation’s handling of textual issues. One experiment with introducing sod resonated deeply with some of the students and complemented the other work we were doing. I share that experiment here. Sod (literally, secret) is a mode of hermeneutical interpretation that sees the characters and storyline as being symbolic of fundamental themes. Although definitions of sod usually include mysticism, the relation to Kabbalah is only that sod reflects an interpretation that directly addresses giving insight into our relationship with God.

Heroes Within Reach

Heroes Within Reach

We read the Bible with the understanding that many of the characters described are our heroes, our Jewish archetypes. We pore over every action, every word, for insight into their thought and character, insight that can inform the same in us. These are not dry annals of the lives of figures from the distant past; these people are as alive today as we are—alive within us, within our synagogues and culture, because we study them so intensively and know them so intimately. Each of us knows the stories so well, that we know what happens between and behind the words.What is a Hero?But what does it mean to consider them heroes? In what sense does, or doesn’t, the Bible portray them as such? And more importantly, how does the Bible express what a hero is, and what makes someone heroic?

Tanakh as a Tool for Building Identity

Tanakh as a Tool for Building Identity

Jewish tradition holds Torah teachers in high esteem, viewing them as more than just conveyors of knowledge. They are seen as spiritual and moral guides, shaping the character and identity of their students. In The Lonely Man of Faith, Rabbi Soloveitchik emphasizes that the role of the Torah teacher goes beyond intellectual instruction; they facilitate a divine encounter, guiding students toward a deeper connection with God. The Talmud (Bava Metzia 33a) elevates the honor due to a Torah teacher above even that of one’s parents, as the teacher introduces the student to the “world to come” through their instruction—a profound form of giving life. These texts paint a picture of the Torah teacher as a builder of Jewish identity, imparting values that help shape a student’s character and moral foundation.

Tanakh as Our Story

Tanakh as Our Story

Tanakh is the story of the Jewish people. This basic component of our identity and our tradition has tremendous spiritual and educational power which, unfortunately, is often untapped. In the following essay, we aim to show how this idea of Tanakh as the grand narrative of the Jewish people can be developed into a powerful educational opportunity. In tapping into Tanakh’s central narrative feature, we are not merely making Tanakh more interesting for our students. Since the times of Moses, the Jewish people has known that a good story does more than just pique an audience’s interest. In the words of Rabbi Sacks, “The Israelites had not yet left Egypt, and yet already Moses was telling them how to tell the story. That is the extraordinary fact. Why so? Why this obsession with storytelling?

Winter 2025 Journal Credits

JEWISHEDUCATIONALEADERSHIP Jewish Educational Leadership is a publication of The Lookstein Center for Jewish Education of Bar Ilan University. Journal Staff Hyim Brandes | EditorChana German | Executive DirectorZvi Grumet | Editor-in-ChiefLeah Herzog | Editorial...

Caring For Our Students & Ourselves In The Face Of Antisemitism

Reach 10,000 Jewish educational professionals. Advertise in the upcoming issue of Jewish Educational Leadership.

Caring For Our Students & Ourselves In The Face Of Antisemitism

Do you want to write for Jewish Educational Leadership? See the Call for Papers for the upcoming issue.

Secret Link